Game designSpellsProgressionBalanceFrench MMORPG

Fifteen Spells per Class, None for Free

A player reports a bug at level 11. Looking into it reveals something worse: a progression system that asked for just one decision in a hundred levels. Here are the spell trees replacing it, and the audit showing our synergies did nothing.

·5 min read ·The Valenya team

A forum player reported something strange at level 11. The game offered a choice of two spells; they picked one, and both appeared on the action bar. The second refused to cast. They added a sensible observation: this choice is permanent, and mistakes are expensive.

The bug was real and is fixed. But looking under the hood revealed something more troubling than the bug.

One decision in a hundred levels

Until now, spells arrived automatically at their tier. Reach level 8, receive Spear of Light. No decision, no cost. Skill points only raised the ranks of spells already acquired, and once in a character's life, at one specific tier, the game demanded an irreversible choice between two options.

The Ranger illustrated the problem better than any speech. It had four spells. With twenty ranks per spell, eighty points maxed everything. A character earns about a hundred over a lifetime. There was literally no tradeoff to make.

What replaces it all

Each class now receives a fifteen-spell tree, divided into three branches over five rows opening at levels 1, 4, 8, 13 and 18. Thirty-four spells were written for it. No existing spell was removed: they changed position, not identity.

Three rules, nothing more.

Every rank costs one skill point, including the first. No spell arrives automatically with a level. A new character starts with one point and chooses where to begin.

A node requires its row's level and at least one rank in its prerequisites. The Cleric's Celestial Judgment cannot open without first investing in Sacred Blaze. A prerequisite opens a door; it excludes nothing.

No branch ever closes. Investing in one forbids nothing in the others. The only tradeoff is budget: twenty ranks across fifteen spells means three hundred possible points against about a hundred earned. You will cover a third of your class. Which third is your choice.

Bridges, not three ladders

The first version of these trees was wrong, and someone had to point it out. We had drawn three parallel chains: one parent per spell, no crossings, one route to each node. A proper skill tree does not look like that.

The corrected shape is a lattice. Six or seven spells per class now require two parents instead of one. Some nodes have no prerequisites even in lower rows: the Barbarian's Whirlwind, Cleric's Aura of Fervor, Bard's Crescendo and Ranger's Grove Call open independently. Above all, bridges cross between branches.

Each is justified by the spell itself. The Barbarian's Earthquake is a sweeping strike into the ground, so it requires Whirlwind as well as Stunning Strike. A Barbarian who has spent a lifetime farming packs reaches Earthquake by a path the duelist does not take. The Cleric's Blinding Smite draws on light as much as fervor. The Ranger's Poisoned Volley falls to the ground, like Grove Call.

In the panel, a branch link descends straight in green. A bridge bends in gold across columns.

Our synergies did nothing

Here is this week's confession. The game already had synergies : investing in a spell strengthens related spells. On paper, that is the heart of a build system. We had never checked the number.

Twenty points in a spell make it 190% stronger. Twenty points in one of its sources added 40%. Feeding a synergy was almost five times less valuable than upgrading the target spell directly. No attentive player would ever invest in a source. Our pretty arrows were decoration.

Synergy rises from 2% to 5% per rank. A maxed source now doubles its target's power. Upgrading source or target becomes a real question, as intended from the start. The impact was measured in the simulator before approval: 9–22% more damage at level 40 depending on the build, and none for the healer.

The same audit found two gaps. Healing Word, shared by Cleric and Bard, was fed only by a Cleric spell, leaving Bards without any synergy for it. And because War Cry deals no damage, its rank changed absolutely nothing about its effect. Every point beyond the first had been wasted since creation. It now feeds Whirlwind, and its description says so plainly.

What changes for you

With the update, all spellbooks reset and all points are refunded, including those spent reaching rank 1. You will reopen your Skills panel with your full pile of points and an empty tree.

Set aside a few minutes. Your action bar will be empty on first launch, and badges will appear on the Skills and Character buttons while you have unspent points.

The character you reload will be the same. Your reasons for building them that way become visible.